Gas Prices and Truck Sales – Not As Related As We Think
Jason Lancaster | Aug 21, 2009 | Comments 5
Auto analysts LOVE to declare that high gas prices will ultimately kill pickup truck sales. At first glance, this reasoning makes some sense – if gas is $5 per gallon and a Tundra has a 26 gallon fuel tank, every fill-up will cost $130. If you just felt a little pain in your gut at that number, you’re not alone. When gas prices approached $5 per gallon this time last year, truck sales fell precipitously.
However, was this a knee-jerk reaction or an indicator of a shift in consumer demand?
Average price per gallon of a gallon of gas from 2003 to 2009
First, let’s consider this question historically.
- In August 2003, gas prices were around $1.50 per gallon. New light truck sales in 2003 (light truck sales are composed of SUVs, trucks, and minivans) were at 7.82 million units.
- In August 2004, gas prices were essentially flat at $1.70 per gallon. New light truck sales were 8.17 million units.
- August 2005 – gas prices jumped 35% to about $2.50 per gallon, new light truck sales were 7.86 million.
- August 2006 – $2.85 per gallon, 7.11 million units.
- August 2007 – about $2.75 per gallon, 7.26 million light trucks sold.
- August 2008 – about $3.80 per gallon, 7.87 million units.
- August 2009 – gas prices about $2.50 per gallon, sales tracking for 5.5 to 6 million light trucks sold.
Correlation? None. Gas prices and light truck sales (stats from GasBuddy.com and Bureau of Transportation Statistics) don’t seem to be very closely related. Granted, light truck sales as reported include some categories of vehicles that aren’t actually light trucks. Still, it’s safe to say that gas prices and truck sales aren’t “tied” to one another.
What about economics? Won’t gas prices impact sales simply because of the expense?
Not as much as some might think.
Let’s say a consumer is choosing between a new Tundra 5.7 and a new Tacoma 4.0. The Tundra, for sake of argument, averages 15mpg. The Tacoma averages 18mpg. According to FuelEconomy.gov, the difference in annual fuel costs between the Tacoma and the Tundra is only $406 – about $34 a month. This is assuming a fuel cost of $1.81 per gallon. Triple the price of gas ($5.40 per gallon), and the cost difference is about $100.
While we’ve never conducted a scientific poll, we’re pretty confident most Tundra owners would spend an extra $100 a month on fuel if it meant having a Tundra 5.7 with twice the capability of a 4.0 Tacoma.
Let’s also consider that many people own pickups as a second or third vehicle. If gas prices increase, will consumers stop buying trucks, or will they simply drive their trucks less?
Let’s also recognize that a person who can afford a new Tundra is probably able to afford a higher than average gas bill. A new Tundra costs $25-$40k dollars, before taxes, interest, and registration fees. If an extra $200 or $300 in fuel costs will “break the budget” compared to buying a new Corolla for $17k, you’re probably not in the market for a big pickup.
The Toyota Prius isn't much of a work truck.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, there’s also the fact that many consumers NEED trucks. If your work requires a truck, if you have a big boat or RV, or if you like to go off-road, you’re not going to be able to buy a new Prius when gas is $5 per gallon – at least not until they make ladder racks and tool boxes for compacts.
Don’t get us wrong – low gas prices are important to the truck market. Truck owners everywhere want low gas prices. However, the idea that truck sales will grind to halt as gas prices increase is completely and totally wrong. Historical data shows that truck sales and gas prices aren’t as closely related as we might think, and the economics of the situation show that high gas prices aren’t nearly the deterrent to truck consumers that analysts make them out to be.
Comments? Would you buy another Tundra if gas was $5 per gallon?
Filed Under: Auto News
I don’t plan on buying another one. In a couple of years the truck is paid off and I really don’t think gas will be an issue. If it was a Crewmax either a Platinum or a Hybrid. If gas was a big deal I’ll take the wife’s Prius from her….hahahha. Right as we speak I go everywhere in the truck hence the 66,000 miles on her at 25 months old. We go to the store, the market, church, and visiting. Very few times we take the Prius. If gas became a problem then we may take the Prius shopping and church but I won’t get rid of the truck. Wife does agree and states boldly we need a truck. So we have one.
Agree with Mickey – not getting rid of the truck as long as I have a need for using the bed. I have smaller vehicles and most of my commuting for work is by motorcycle. It all balances out for me in the end.
I think a lot of Americans feel the exact same way.
I agree, trucks are needed and nice to have when you need to tow and haul items. It does make me think though when gas is over 3 bucks per gallon to take the corolla to the store or to visit family and friends on weekends instead of the tundra simply because the truck is not needed and gets 1/2 the gas mpg as the corolla. I was thinking forever a lot about getting the 4.6L vs. 5.7L tundra in my 2010, but the dealer convinced me for $5.00 per week driving and 20 bucks per month extra = about 250 bucks per year extra in gas savings is NOT too much extra to be paying when the gas mpg is about 2 mpg less in the 5.7L vs. the 4.6L. Besides, the resale value of the 5.7L will and should be better and get most of the 1200 bucks extra to get the bigger engine come trade in or resell time. Sales are not effected that much with high gas prices, I just think truck owners think about taking their more fuel efficient car to go more places and let the tundra sit more when you really don’t need a truck. I bought a motorcycle that gets 36 mpg (honda valkyrie that smokes the harleys and even my tundra but not supercharged – another story) when gas was over 4 bucks per gallon last year, but now I don’t ride it as much since gas is down to around 2.56 per gallon now.
I love my motorcycle and convinced myself it was great to get it for HOV and save on gas. But I’m not that broke/cheap I can’t break out the truck when I want to be totally comfortable and tote whatever’s necessary. Most people that can’t afford the gas for their vehicle of choice probably have bad budgeting and/or priorities.